A is brother of B, B is wife of C, C is son of D and D is wife of E. What is E to B?

Question

Accepted Answer

To determine the relationship between E and B, let's analyze the given information step by step:

1. **A is the brother of B**: This tells us that A and B are siblings.

2. **B is the wife of C**: This indicates that B is married to C.

3. **C is the son of D**: This means D is the parent of C.

4. **D is the wife of E**: This tells us that D is married to E.

Now, let's piece together these relationships:

- Since B is the wife of C, and C is the son of D, B is the daughter-in-law of D.
- D, being the wife of E, makes E the husband of D.
- Therefore, E is the father-in-law of B because E is the father of B's husband, C.

Now, let's explain why the other options are incorrect:

1. **Son-in-law**: This option is incorrect because E is not married to B's child. Instead, E is married to D, who is C's parent.

3. **Brother-in-law**: This option is incorrect because E is not a sibling of B's spouse or B's sibling's spouse. E is the spouse of B's parent-in-law.

4. **Mother-in-law**: This option is incorrect because E is male, as indicated by being the husband of D, and thus cannot be B's mother-in-law.

In conclusion, based on the relationships outlined, E is correctly identified as B's father-in-law, which is why Option 2 is the correct answer.