Pointing towards a photograph Vishal says, she is the sister of my grand-father's only son. How the woman in the photograph is related to Vishal ?

Question

Accepted Answer

To determine how the woman in the photograph is related to Vishal, let's break down the statement: "She is the sister of my grandfather's only son."

1. **Understanding the Statement:**
   - Vishal's "grandfather's only son" refers to Vishal's father. This is because the only son of Vishal's grandfather would be Vishal's father.
   - The woman in the photograph is described as the "sister" of Vishal's father.

2. **Relation to Vishal:**
   - If the woman is the sister of Vishal's father, she is Vishal's paternal aunt. In family terms, a paternal aunt is the sister of one's father.

3. **Explanation of Options:**
   - **Option 1: Maternal Aunty** - This would imply that the woman is the sister of Vishal's mother. However, the statement specifies that she is the sister of Vishal's father's side, not the mother's side. Therefore, this option is incorrect.
   - **Option 2: Paternal Aunty** - As explained, the woman is the sister of Vishal's father, making her Vishal's paternal aunt. This aligns perfectly with the given statement, making this the correct option.
   - **Option 3: Sister** - This would mean the woman is Vishal's sibling. However, the statement clearly indicates a generational difference, as she is related to Vishal's father, not directly to Vishal as a sibling. Thus, this option is incorrect.
   - **Option 4: Mother** - The statement specifies that the woman is the sister of Vishal's father, not his wife. Therefore, she cannot be Vishal's mother. This option is incorrect.

In conclusion, based on the logical breakdown of the relationships described, Option 2, "Paternal Aunty," is indeed the correct answer.