Who said "Music is for Soul and Gymnastic is for body"?

Question

Accepted Answer

The correct option is (2):
This iconic quote is a direct reflection of Plato's philosophical approach to ideal citizenship and education, as detailed in his major work, *The Republic*. Plato believed that a balanced person required simultaneous development in two distinct, yet complementary, areas: the spirit and the flesh. He advocated for a bipartite curriculum for his ideal citizens, the Guardians: **Gymnastic for the body** and **Music for the soul**. In this context, 'Music' was a comprehensive term referring to all cultural, liberal arts, and intellectual training—including poetry, literature, and philosophy—that would instill rhythm, harmony, and virtue into the rational and spirited parts of the soul. 'Gymnastic' represented the physical conditioning necessary to make the body strong, healthy, and obedient to the mind. The harmony between these two forms of training was intended to create an individual who was neither brutish (too much body training) nor effeminate (too much mental training), thereby achieving the ideal of *kalokagathia*, the beautiful and good person.

The incorrect option is (1):
Aristotle, a student of Plato, was also a profound educational theorist who discussed the connection between the soul and the body. However, this specific dualistic phrasing is distinctly Platonic and appears in *The Republic*, not in Aristotle's core writings like *Politics* or *Nicomachean Ethics*. While Aristotle highly valued physical education for health and preparedness for war, his ultimate focus in human development was on the cultivation of intellectual virtues and practical wisdom (*phronesis*). His pedagogical discussions focus more on the importance of habit formation and the pursuit of knowledge for its own sake, which differs from Plato's precise framing of 'music' as the training of the soul.

The incorrect option is (3):
John Dewey was a major American philosopher and education reformer who lived from 1859 to 1952. His educational philosophy, known as Progressive Education, centered on experiential learning, the scientific method, and preparing students for life in a democracy. Dewey’s concept of education as a continuous process of reconstruction of experience places him firmly in the 20th century, thousands of years after Plato. Therefore, this classical quote, rooted in ancient Greek dualism, cannot be attributed to the modern, pragmatic educational theories of John Dewey.

The incorrect option is (4):
The *Iliad* is a monumental epic poem that details the events of the Trojan War, traditionally attributed to the ancient Greek poet Homer. As a piece of literature, the *Iliad* is an object of study within the "Music" portion of the Platonic curriculum, but it is not a person or philosopher who produced educational theory. It is a literary text, not the source of philosophical maxims on the structure of education, making its attribution as the author of this quote contextually and factually incorrect.