Who among the following are commentators of 'Sangeet Ratnakar' ?
(i) Dattil
(ii) Kallinath
(iii) Abhinav Gupt
(iv) Singh Bhupal

Question

Accepted Answer

Option 1 is the correct answer, which states that Kallinath (ii) and Singh Bhupal (iv) are commentators of 'Sangeet Ratnakar'. Here is a detailed explanation supporting this choice:

1. **Kallinath (ii)**: Kallinath is a well-known commentator of 'Sangeet Ratnakar'. He wrote a detailed commentary on this seminal text, which is one of the most important treatises on Indian classical music and dance. His work has been instrumental in interpreting and understanding the original text written by Sharngadeva.

2. **Singh Bhupal (iv)**: Singh Bhupal is also recognized as a commentator of 'Sangeet Ratnakar'. His contributions have been acknowledged in the context of providing insights and interpretations that help in the understanding of the text.

Now, let's explain why the other options are incorrect:

- **Option 2: (i), (ii) and (iii)**: This option includes Dattil (i) and Abhinav Gupt (iii) along with Kallinath (ii). Dattil is not known to be a commentator of 'Sangeet Ratnakar'. Abhinav Gupt, although a significant figure in Indian philosophy and aesthetics, is not recognized as a commentator of this particular text.

- **Option 3: (ii), (iii) and (iv)**: This option includes Abhinav Gupt (iii) along with Kallinath (ii) and Singh Bhupal (iv). As mentioned earlier, Abhinav Gupt is not associated with the commentary of 'Sangeet Ratnakar', making this option incorrect.

- **Option 4: (i), (ii) and (iv)**: This option includes Dattil (i) along with Kallinath (ii) and Singh Bhupal (iv). Since Dattil is not a commentator of 'Sangeet Ratnakar', this option is incorrect.

In conclusion, Option 1 is the correct answer because it accurately identifies Kallinath and Singh Bhupal as commentators of 'Sangeet Ratnakar', while the other options incorrectly include individuals who are not recognized commentators of this text.